Dear Daddy

Dear Daddy

Double our Pleasure

Then they turned to me...

Jenna Hayes's avatar
Jenna Hayes
Mar 12, 2026
∙ Paid

Some nights take unexpected but more that welcome twists. Once recent date started as one of those nights with a guy you’ve already clicked with a few times — comfortable, no first-date jitters, just easy anticipation. And that comfort lead to double the fun :)

Jeff and I had “dated” a handful of times before. I knew his vibe: confident but chill, great at putting me at ease, and his place felt familiar — big bed, low lights, always clean sheets. We’d texted about a lifestyle bar he liked — low-key spot, good dancing, no pressure. I said “sounds intriguing 👀” because the idea made my stomach do that naughty flip. We set the date, nothing locked in beyond “let’s go see.”

I showed up in my usual cute-but-not-slutty uniform: high-waisted black jeans, soft off-the-shoulder sweater that hugs just right, hair down and sweet smile on autopilot. Jeff was waiting, easy grin, drink already ordered. We talked, laughed, hit the dance floor as the place woke up. It started quiet, but after 11 the energy shifted: bass thumping, lights dimmer, bodies closer. We danced like we knew each other’s rhythm — hands on hips, my back to his chest, that building heat.

I went for another round at the bar, and that’s when I met him. Our third. Tall, dark hair, relaxed smile. We started chatting while waiting — easy, natural. He cracked a dumb joke about the fog machine looking like a bad 80s video, made me laugh. That click happened fast. So I said, “Come meet my friend” and brought him over

.

Jeff sized him up, grinned, bought him a drink. The three of us vibed — more talking, more dancing, touches lingering. After about 40 minutes of that delicious tension, Jeff leaned in: “My place is close. You two wanna come?” We all looked at each other, laughed that excited-nervous laugh, and said yes.

Dear Daddy is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Get 7 day free trial

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Jenna Hayes · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture